Statement from Francis Sullivan, CEO Catholic Church’s Truth Justice and Healing Council

Today the Royal Commission has released the full report of its survey results on claims made against Catholic organisations for alleged child sexual abuse by their personnel.

As such, it is the composite of Church records since 1950, of claims of abuse.

As we know these claims comprise records of known offenders, alleged offenders and unidentified offenders.

Over the years, dioceses and religious orders have used a variety of processes to determine the veracity of these claims.

Some claims were too obvious to warrant any investigation and were accepted on the information provided by the survivor.

Others were substantiated by formal investigations, police referrals or corroborated evidence.

Others proved difficult to establish because victims couldn’t recall the actual names of their abusers or were uncertain over the extent to which some people were involved in their assault.

So, the data reflects the scope of alleged abuse within the Church. It does not break this abuse down into categories of certainty because Church Authorities themselves have struggled to be that accurate.

Today’s data provides new insight into some aspects of child sexual abuse within the Catholic Church including:

  • a massive drop off in child sexual abuse claims from the peak in the 1970s of some 1,245 claims in that decade to 41 claims in the 2010s (figure 3, pg 21);
  • a massive drop-off in the number of alleged clerical perpetrators from a peak in the 1960s of more than 400 to less than 10 in the 2010s (figure 4, pg 22);
  • a massive drop-off in the number of claims in schools from more than 600 in the 1970s to around 25 in the 2010s (figure 32, pg 74);
  • across all the disoseses and orders where abuse has occurred some $258 million in redress has been paid;
  • nearly half of all the claims for redress went through the Church’s Towards Healing and Melbourne Response; and
  • that the average payments made through Towards Healing and The Melbourne Response were considerably lower than payments received through civil proceeding and other redress processes.

Just a little about the difference in these redress payments.

There is one view that will contend people were pushed into Towards Healing and The Melbourne Responses because the payments were low and it saved the Church millions of dollars.

There is another view that people went to Towards Healing and The Melbourne Response because they had no other options, because they had limited recollections and little evidence to pursue a legal claim.

Wherever the truth lies, what is clear is that payments made to survivors from Church Authorities over many years have varied widely and that there has been no consistency in how much they received.

This is at the very heart of the call by survivors and many others, including the Catholic Church, for a national independent redress scheme, coordinated by the Commonwealth Government which will determine redress payments to be paid by the institution in which the abuse took place.

As I have said on many occasions, the days of the Church investigating itself must be over – today’s data reinforces this position 

As has been said today, we know that far more people were abused than have come forward.

These statistics are not the full story and, if anything, are understated rather than overstated.

Importantly, the data shows the amount of time alleged perpetrators remained in dioceses and religious orders.

This gives an important indication of the level of potential risk children may have been in across the various dioceses and religious orders.

A full analysis of this data will form the basis for policy developments in the Church.

We will learn from it and use it as further impetus for change in the church, as a basis for better policies and procedures.

That analysis will happen soon but right now is the time for the Church to be humble, receptive and in a state of confession.

A copy of the statement is available on the Royal Commission’s website.

The Truth Justice and Healing Council is coordinating the Catholic Church’s response to the Royal Commission into Institutional Responses to Child Sexual Abuse.

Back to List


More News


10.06.2019

Announcement of National Themes for Discernment opens next phase for Plenary Council

The Plenary Council 2020 moves into its next phase of preparation today with the announcement of the National Themes for Discernment that emerged from a historic process of listening to the voices of more than 222,000 people. Between May 2018 and March 2019, ...

Read Full Article
10.05.2019

New laws further sign that abuse prevention in Church priority

New laws further sign that abuse prevention is Church priority The Australian Catholic Bishops Conference has welcomed Pope Francis’ new document on the investigation and reporting of abuse within Church settings, which enshrines some measures long in pl...

Read Full Article
22.04.2019

Joint Statement after Sri Lanka bombings

Joint Statement from Catholic and Anglican Bishops on Sri Lanka bombings At Easter Christians gather all around the world to celebrate the good news of the resurrection of Jesus Christ. In Sri Lanka joy has turned to sorrow with the terrorist attacks on church...

Read Full Article
16.04.2019

Easter Message from Most Rev. Time Harris, Bishop of Townsville

2019 Easter Message At Easter, we celebrate Jesus risen from the dead and we sing with gusto “Alleluia”.  Our faith tells us that it happened and yet do our lives truly reflect that it happened? I mean, because Jesus rose from the dead, death ...

Read Full Article
20.03.2019

Bishops of Oceania visit local Imam

Bishops of Oceania visit local Townsville Imam During the executive meeting of the Federation of Catholic Bishops Conferences of Oceania the bishops took time to visit the local Imam and pay their respects and deliver a statement of support for the communities...

Read Full Article
15.03.2019

New Executive Director of Centacare North Queensland appointed

New Executive Director of Centacare North Queensland  After an extensive recruitment process, today Most Rev. Tim Harris, Bishop of Townsville has appointed Ms Paula Washington as the new Executive Director of Centacare North Queensland. Paula will take...

Read Full Article
17.12.2018

Report outlines Church’s progress since Royal Commission ended

The Australian Catholic Bishops Conference and Catholic Religious Australia have submitted a joint report to the National Office for Child Safety (NOCS) on the Catholic Church’s implementation of the recommendations of the Royal Commission into Instituti...

Read Full Article
22.10.2018

Catholic Church stands with Prime Minister, renews apology

Catholic Church stands with Prime Minister, renews apology The leaders of Catholic Religious Australia (CRA) and the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference (ACBC) have welcomed Prime Minister Scott Morrison’s apology to survivors of institutional child s...

Read Full Article
More Links in this section